ΞAskAurelius.ai answers

How do I design a game system that actually holds together?

You can tweak a single mechanic and make it feel good. But designing a whole system where the parts hold together as one thing still eludes you. That is a real jump. Adjusting a piece is craft. Making the pieces into a coherent whole is a different, harder skill, and it is learnable. A system holds together when everything serves one clear purpose. When it falls apart, it is usually because the parts are each good on their own but pulling in different directions. Before you tune the pieces, you have to know what the whole thing is for, the one feeling or goal it exists to create. Next time, write down in a single sentence what the system is supposed to do. Then check each mechanic against it: does this serve that purpose, or fight it? Cut or fix what fights. A system that holds together is not a pile of good parts. It is many parts aimed at one thing.

Aurelius
Online
The coach is replying…