How do I give honest design critique without crushing the person?
You can take critique now, which is real growth. Giving it is the harder half, because you can feel the weight your words carry and you do not want to flatten someone with them. That care is exactly why you will be good at it. The people who crush others with feedback are the ones who never worry about it. Honest and kind are not opposites. The trick is to aim at the work, not the person, and to be clear about the goal you both share. Say what is not working and why, plainly, then say what would make it stronger. Keep it about the design and its purpose, and the honesty stops feeling like an attack. Vagueness to spare feelings actually helps no one; clear and warm does. Next time, lead with the shared goal, name the specific thing holding the work back, and offer a direction forward. Speak to a colleague you respect, not to someone you are grading. Done that way, honest critique lifts people instead of crushing them, and they leave the room wanting to make the work better, not smaller.