How do I handle being good at reading and influencing people?
You have a real skill. You can read almost anyone and get them to open up. And you have started to feel uneasy about how powerful that is, and how easily it could be misused. That wariness is not a problem to fix. It is your conscience keeping pace with your ability, and that is exactly as it should be. The skill itself is neither good nor bad. A blade cuts for the surgeon and the thief alike. What decides its worth is the aim you point it at and the lines you will not cross. The fact that you feel the weight of it means you are the kind of person who should hold it. The dangerous ones are those who never feel it at all. So make your discomfort useful. Decide, plainly, the lines you will not cross even when you could, and revisit them. Use what you have to get at the truth and protect people, not to win for its own sake. A power you stay wary of is a power that stays clean. Keep watching it, and it will keep serving something worth serving.