How do I handle evasive and hostile witnesses in a deposition?
You can run a solid deposition. Where you still lose ground is with the witness who dodges or fights you, the one who will not give a straight answer. That is the hardest part of the skill, and it is normal to still be building it. A cooperative witness tests your preparation; a hostile one tests your patience and control. The evasive witness wants you rattled, so the first move is to stay calm and slow. You control the pace, not them. Ask short, closed questions that leave no room to wander, and when they dodge, simply ask again, and again, without heat. Their evasion becomes obvious on the record when you stay steady while they squirm. Patience is a weapon here, not a weakness. Before your next tough deposition, write your key questions tight and closed, and decide in advance that you will not let frustration show. The calmer you stay, the more their behavior works against them. You are not being beaten by these witnesses. You are learning the part of the craft where composure matters more than cleverness.