How do I handle outages I've never seen before without panicking?
You have got most incidents handled now. It is the strange new ones, the outages you have never seen, that still leave you scrambling and shaken. That is not a sign you are bad at this. By definition, a novel problem is one your experience has not met yet. Everyone scrambles at the true unknown. What separates steady responders from panicked ones is not knowing every answer. It is having a method when there is no answer yet. Check what changed. Narrow down where it is breaking. Slow the bleeding before you chase the root cause. A calm process beats a fast guess every time. Write yourself a simple checklist for unknown outages, the first five moves you make no matter what is broken. Keep it where you will see it at 3 a.m. When the strange one hits, you will not be starting from panic. You will be starting from step one, and that is often enough to steady your hands.