How do I handle tricky pay fairness questions at work?
You have grown into the work. You can run compensation day to day. What still trips you are the equity questions and the hard exceptions, the cases where fairness gets tangled and there is no clean formula. Those are supposed to be hard. They involve people's sense of their own worth, which no spreadsheet fully settles. Here is what steadies it. There is rarely one perfectly fair answer, only a defensible one you can explain honestly. Stop hunting for the solution that makes everyone feel treated exactly right, because it does not exist. Aim instead for consistency and reasons you would stand behind if they were said out loud. Fairness people can trust is fairness they can understand. So when a hard exception lands, write down the principle you are using before you decide the number. If the principle holds across cases, the decision is sound even if someone is unhappy. You will not eliminate the discomfort. You will replace guessing with a standard. That is what makes the hard calls survivable, and it is how you grow past this stage.