How do I learn to tell a good weld from one that will fail?
Right now every weld looks about the same to you, and that is unsettling because so much rides on the difference. But this is not a sign you lack the eye. It is a sign you are at the beginning. No one is born able to read a weld. It is learned, bead by bead, over time. The way through is not to trust your gut yet, but to build it. Learn the specific signs one at a time: what good penetration looks like, where cracks like to start, how a cold lap gives itself away. Judgment feels like instinct in the end, but it is really a stack of small things you learned to notice. You are assembling that stack now. Find someone whose eye you trust and look at welds beside them. Ask what they see that you do not, and why. Compare good and failed examples side by side until the difference stops being a mystery and starts being obvious. The skill will come. Give it the time and the attention it asks for, and one day you will wonder how it ever looked the same.