How do I mentor a student who keeps struggling or pushing back?
You can guide the students who are ready. The ones who flounder no matter what you offer, or who resist the help outright, are a different weight. Feeling defeated by them does not mean you are a poor mentor. It means you have already succeeded with everyone whose path was clearer. Here is a hard and freeing truth: you cannot want a student's growth more than they do. You can offer, model, encourage, and stay open, but you cannot climb the hill for them. When you take their floundering as your personal failure, you carry a burden that was never fully yours to carry. Keep the door open without exhausting yourself against a wall. Tell the resistant student plainly that you believe in what they could do and that you will be there when they are ready, then let the timing be theirs. Some students only reach back years later. Your job is to be a mentor they can return to, not to force a change on their schedule. Offer steadily, and release the outcome.