How do I rigorously evaluate an AI model?
You can tell when output looks good, but rigorous evaluation defeats you, and that gap is worth closing because looks good is exactly how bad models pass. Your eye catches the obvious; rigor catches what the eye misses. The two are different skills, and the second can be learned. Rigor means deciding what good actually means before you look, in specific measurable terms, then testing against cases you chose on purpose rather than the ones that happen to look nice. It means checking the edges, the rare inputs, and the places failure would hurt most, not just the average. It means being willing to be proven wrong by your own tests. Impression is fast and comfortable; rigor is slow and honest, and only the honest one protects you. Start small and concrete. For your next evaluation, write down what success means in plain terms and build a handful of hard test cases before you judge anything. Run the model against those, not against your gut. Do that a few times and rigor stops being a mystery and becomes a habit.