ΞAskAurelius.ai answers
How do I run a usability test that actually teaches me something?
Showing someone a design and testing it feel similar, but they teach very different things. A demo makes you feel good. A real test is built to make you a little uncomfortable, because that discomfort is where the learning lives. The trick is to stop guiding. Give the person a real task, then be quiet and let them struggle. Do not explain, do not rescue, do not ask if they like it. Every time you jump in to help, you erase the very thing you needed to see. Try this once: write one honest task, hand it over, and say nothing but tell me what you are thinking. Watch where they get stuck. That single stuck moment will teach you more than an hour of praise. The test works when it shows you what you did not want to see.