How do I stay fair and rigorous in peer review despite my biases?
You can review competently now. The harder thing is holding rigor and fairness together while knowing your own biases are in the room. That tension trips you because you are honest enough to admit the biases exist, which most reviewers never do. That honesty is a strength, not the problem. Rigor and fairness are not really at war. Rigor means judging the work by clear, consistent standards. Fairness means applying those same standards to everyone, including the work you instinctively like or dislike. Your bias does its damage when it quietly changes the standard depending on whose paper it is. The fix is to make the standard explicit and hold it steady. Before you write your review, name the criteria you are judging by, then check each point against the work itself, not your gut feeling about it. Ask, would I say this if a different author had written it? That single question catches most bias in the act. You cannot erase your leanings, but you can refuse to let them move the bar.