How do I stop seeing what I want to see in my data?
You feel the pull to find the result you are hoping for, and you are honest enough to notice it happening. That honesty already sets you apart. The scary researchers are not the ones who feel this temptation. They are the ones who never admit they do. Naming it is your protection. Wanting a certain answer is human. The mind bends toward hope without asking permission. So you cannot rely on simply being fair-minded in the moment, because the moment is exactly when the bias is strongest. You need rules set earlier, when you had nothing to gain. Decide in advance how you will analyze the data and what would count as a null result, and write it down before you look. Better yet, have a colleague check your reasoning. You are not doubting your character. You are building a fence so your character never gets tested at its weakest point.