How do I tell if a sales rep will actually perform?
The interview rewards people who are good at interviewing, which is not the same skill as selling. You have felt the gap: the polished candidate who cannot close, the quiet one who turns out to be your best. Reading real ability under the performance is genuinely hard, and knowing that already makes you better at it. The interview room is the worst place to judge selling, because both of you are selling. So stop relying on it alone. Make candidates do the job in the room. A mock call, a real objection, a cold open. How they handle being tested tells you more than any answer to what is your greatest weakness. Add one live exercise to your next loop. Give them a scenario and play a tough buyer, then watch how they think on their feet, not how they rehearse. Real selling ability shows up under a little pressure, and that is exactly what an interview usually removes.