How do I understand why people get paid what they do?
You can administer compensation, run the process, move the numbers. What eludes you is the why beneath it, the philosophy of who gets paid what and on what grounds. Noticing that gap is a good sign. It means you want the work to make sense, not just function. Here is the honest truth. Pay is not a pure science. It is a mix of market rates, what the role creates, internal fairness, and what the company can afford, all in tension. There is no single formula because it is a set of judgment calls dressed up as numbers. Understanding the philosophy means understanding those trade-offs, not finding one hidden rule. So learn it from the reasoning, not the spreadsheets. Ask whoever sets pay at your company to walk you through why two similar roles are paid differently, and listen for the principle underneath. Do that a few times and the logic starts to show itself. The philosophy is not written down anywhere clean. You absorb it by asking why, one real decision at a time.