Why do I take feedback fine in private but shut down in front of others?
In private, your mind stays open and you actually use what you hear. In front of others, something older takes over. It is not about the feedback anymore, it is about being seen falling short. Your body reads the room as a threat and pulls the shutters down. That is a wiring response, not a character flaw, and plenty of thoughtful people share it. The shutdown is trying to protect you from shame. But it also robs you of the moment, and it makes you look less capable than you are. The way through is not to force yourself to perform calm. It is to lower the stakes of the moment so your thinking brain can stay online. You do that by having a plan for what to do when the heat rises. Give yourself one simple line to reach for: something like, that is useful, let me sit with it and come back to you. It buys you time, keeps you from freezing, and moves the real processing to where you do it best. Used a few times, it teaches your body that public feedback is survivable, and the shutdown slowly loses its grip.