Is it wrong to shape my interview answers to what they want to hear?
You are good at this. You have a deep set of stories and you can shape any one of them to show an interviewer exactly what they are looking for. Somewhere in that skill sits a quiet question: is this honest, or am I just telling them what they want to hear. Shaping is not lying, as long as the core is true. Choosing which real story to tell, and framing it toward what matters to them, is simply good communication. It crosses a line only when you invent things you did not do or become a person you are not to get the job. Watch that line, and you are fine. Before your next interview, pick stories you are actually proud of, not just ones that flatter the role. When what you present matches who you really are, the skill stops feeling like a performance and starts feeling like the truth, well told. That is a gift, not a trick.