I've gotten so good at selling that I distrust my own sincerity, is that normal?
You learned to persuade so well that now, even off the clock, you catch yourself wondering whether anything you say is real. That doubt is actually a good sign. A person with no conscience would not ask the question. It means the honest part of you is still awake and uneasy about the tools you use all day. The skill of the pitch is not the problem. The problem is when it stops being something you pick up and put down, and starts feeling like who you are. You can be persuasive at work and plain-spoken at home. The trick is to notice the difference on purpose, so the mask does not fuse to your face. Practice sincerity somewhere the stakes are zero. With the people you love, say the simple true thing and stop, no angle, no close. It will feel oddly bare at first. That bareness is your real voice, and the more you use it off the clock, the easier it becomes to trust that you still have one.