Should I trust lead scores or my own judgment?
You have leaned on lead scores to decide where to spend your time, and you have been burned both ways: a high score that went nowhere, a low one you skipped that would have closed. So now you are not sure whether to trust the number or yourself. That doubt is healthy. It means you are paying attention. A lead score is a guess dressed up as a fact. It is built from patterns, and patterns are usually right and sometimes badly wrong. The mistake is not using it. The mistake is obeying it. It should inform your judgment, not replace it. Use the score as a first sort, then look with your own eyes at anything that feels off. When a low score has strong signs of a real buyer, trust what you see and note why. Over time you will learn where the model is blind, and that mix of number and judgment is worth more than either alone.