LibraryScenariosWhen your community splits over whether to seek punishment or restorative justice
Scenario

When your community splits over whether to seek punishment or restorative justice

Our neighborhood association is trying to decide whether to support a restorative justice program for the teenager who vandalized our community garden, but half the members want him prosecuted and banned from the space and the other half think punishment won't actually repair the harm, and every meeting gets more heated.

Juana
Online
The coach is replying

More people experience this than they realize.

What we've seen

The group is confronting fundamental disagreements about whether justice means punishment or repair, and whether forgiveness requires accountability.

Ideas that help explain it
Worth thinking about

“Where Are You with Justice and forgiveness — the tension?”

If this sounds familiar, the Library can help you find the bigger picture.