LibraryScenariosWhen you're a public defender torn between system and client
Scenario

When you're a public defender torn between system and client

I'm a public defender and I know my client is probably guilty but I also know he won't get a fair trial because he's Black and poor and I'm losing sleep over whether fighting harder makes me complicit in a broken system or if giving up makes me complicit in his destruction.

Juana
Online
The coach is replying

More people experience this than they realize.

What we've seen

The moral weight of operating within an unjust system while trying to serve justice creates an impossible ethical bind.

Ideas that help explain it
Worth thinking about

“Where Are You with Criminal justice systems globally?”

If this sounds familiar, the Library can help you find the bigger picture.